Call us     +88029110246, +8801733332267 - 72            +61401043939, +610401224465            +353899742487
Email usinfo@eduaid.net

NEWS & EVENTS

Migration & visa related news

March 27, 2015

European politicians envy Canada’s points system for migrants. But how well has it worked?


March 27, 2015 When political parties across the world complain about their own country’s “inefficient” way of coping with immigration, they frequently refer to us in Canada. The “points system” of selecting permanent immigrants according to their human capital – as calculated according to age, education, occupation, language ability and optional job offer – holds out the promise that the immigration system can do what eugenics could not: control entry into the political community of only the best and the brightest. And the fact that a Conservative government manages to cater to its anti-immigrant base while cultivating a substantial immigrant vote arouses curiosity and envy among European politicians of all stripes.

The points system has been one of the two main portals into Canada since the 1960s (the other one being kinship). Yet its role is frequently overstated. Over the past 50 years, 60-70% of permanent immigrants Canada admitted annually (out of a total of about 250,000) gained admission through a family bond to an applicant under the points system, or to a permanent resident or citizen already in Canada. In other words, the vast majority of immigration to Canada (and the US) was and remains kinship migration.

Historically, this openness to family migration was driven by self-interest. Nation-building requires people. Canada could not hope to attract and retain preferred economic actors without allowing them to bring their family; in any event, an intact family unit was more economically productive, socially integrated, and likely to spend and invest domestically rather than remitting back to a family residing abroad. The points system, along with family migration, was a vehicle for channelling mass migration, not a tool for restricting it.

The points system has also had limitations: one was the uncontrolled inventory created by a supply-driven system without formal intake quotas. By 2011, the backlog ballooned to more than 400,000 unprocessed applications. The government resolved the problem by halting intake and tossing all submitted applications into the rubbish bin.

The other major flaw was brain waste. The stereotype of the taxi-driving doctor or pizza-delivery engineer is exaggerated but not unfounded. Underemployment of newcomers is a symptom of the mismatch between the federal government’s admission criteria and restrictive credential recognition practices of professional licensing bodies. An even greater barrier to labour market integration is employers’ tendency to insist on Canadian education and experience. On paper, the points system may have been indifferent to race, religion, and ethnicity but in practice the Canadian labour market is not. (A 2011 study showed that, all other things being equal, the CVs of people with foreign-sounding names had a 30% lower chance of being called for an interview).

The points system did excel at the large-scale selection of middle-class, educated, hard-working and ambitious parents, who strove to rise the next generation of highly educated and productive Canadian citizen children. This was its real success. In tandem with family-based migration and, to a much smaller extent, refugee admissions, it has yielded an immigrant population that is widely dispersed across the spectrum of class, race, religion and national origin. This has had significantly positive, if hard to quantify, implications for immigrant integration, and the relative durability of a multiculturalist ethos.

Yet much of this must now be framed in the past tense, because the present Conservative government is busily dismantling the pillars of Canada’s immigration and integration system, including the points system. Since assuming power in 2006, the Conservative government gradually eliminated admission of economic immigrants from abroad as permanent residents. It substituted a massive employer-driven, de-regulated, guest-worker regime in which a minority of temporary workers classified as “high skill” will be eligible to transition to permanent residence. The remaining temporary foreign workers are deemed good enough to work, but not good enough to stay: they must depart Canada after four years and are barred from returning for a further four years.

Predictably, some unscrupulous employers systematically abused the new guest-worker regime by exploiting temporary foreign workers, and replacing Canadian and permanent residents with cheaper, precarious temporary foreign workers. In the wake of the inevitable scandal the government promised to get tough on employers but, almost a year later, it has conducted no workplace inspections. The equally foreseeable result of the “4 in, 4 out” rule will be to drive significant numbers of temporary foreign workers underground at the end of four years, where they can be even more vulnerable as non-status workers. Fittingly, this foolish rule was enacted on 1 April 2011; the government is cued to start manufacturing “illegal immigrants” on April 1, 2015.

In January 2015, the federal government introduced the “express entry” model, which effectively replaces the points system for selection of permanent economic immigrants. The model is long on fanfare, short on content, and devoid of accountability. It appears designed to achieve two objectives: inventory control and the privatisation of selection. Although nominally employing a version of the points system, it appears that possession of a Canadian job offer is a necessary and possibly sufficient condition for success. For a range of reasons connected to the nature of the Canadian labour market, it seems improbable that this model will yield the number of highly skilled immigrants that Canada needs, or that the old points system could generate.

The great irony is that while European states look to past Canadian policies for inspiration, the Conservative government has been borrowing and extending contemporary European and Australian policies on how to delay or prevent family reunification by spouses, parents and children, how to deter asylum seekers, and how to make citizenship harder to get and easier to lose.

Consider Canada’s reputation as a haven for refugees: after undertaking to resettle 1,300 Syrian refugees in 2014, the government proved unable to locate more than a dozen deserving refugees from among the 3 million Syrians who fled, until a concerted public shaming forced their hand.

And the federal government’s policy on healthcare for asylum seekers would, for example, deny publicly insured life-saving treatment to a Mexican or Hungarian child hit by a car, or having an asthma attack. A Canadian court declared it an unconstitutional exercise in cruel and inhuman treatment; the government is appealing the ruling.

[eduaid Newsdesk, Source: Click here to view the news]




More News

November 21, 2017

Economic Miracle of ...


November 20, 2017

UN tells Australia t...


November 20, 2017

One plus one makes m...


October 26, 2017

Migration Helps Fuel...


October 26, 2017

Young entrepreneurs ...


September 25, 2017

Here are the top 10 ...


September 20, 2017

White Australia Poli...


September 19, 2017

‘Australia’s going t...


September 19, 2017

Global panel of scho...


August 28, 2017

Skilled Migration to...


August 24, 2017

How Many Americans W...


August 24, 2017

Australians look to ...


August 17, 2017

Citizenship rules ma...


August 17, 2017

Kiwis, Japanese, Bri...


August 10, 2017

Trump looks to Austr...


July 24, 2017

State of the States:...


July 13, 2017

Immigration Departme...


July 12, 2017

How young, educated ...


July 11, 2017

Migrants are stoppin...


July 11, 2017

Census 2016 reveals ...


June 30, 2017

IMMIGRATION NEWS ALE...







April 27, 2017

Jodie van Deventer: ...


March 6, 2017

Why are the world's ...


December 19, 2016

VN, Australia sign a...


December 18, 2016

Baby boom saves West...


December 17, 2016

One in five Pacific ...


December 14, 2016

TIM STERN is joining...


December 3, 2016

Business Migration t...


December 3, 2016

Australia could doub...


November 18, 2016

Australia 'has plent...


November 16, 2016

10,000 Americans reg...


November 15, 2016

There's nothing to f...


November 11, 2016

Some Americans look ...


November 9, 2016

Australia may drop G...


November 8, 2016

Major changes propos...


November 4, 2016

Extra points for int...


October 25, 2016

Brexit: Google sees ...


September 23, 2016

Migration to Australia


July 20, 2016

Explainer: what is A...


June 20, 2016

Can an Engineer earn...








April 23, 2016

Melbourne named worl...


March 30, 2016

British public must ...


March 5, 2016

Why Australia needs ...


March 3, 2016

Sydney hosts the Big...


January 23, 2016

Migration Opportunit...


December 18, 2015

Australia ranks seco...


November 9, 2015

Australia Tops Educa...


October 31, 2015

Adelaide’s Lord Ma...


October 19, 2015

USA News: DHS propos...


October 14, 2015

UK News: Boris Johns...


October 1, 2015

Mapped: How the way ...


September 14, 2015

Why is EU struggling...


September 10, 2015

Australia - Boost fo...


September 8, 2015

International studen...


September 7, 2015

An Australian points...


September 4, 2015

Migrant crisis: One ...


September 3, 2015

Millionaires Migrati...


August 29, 2015

Migration the key to...


August 18, 2015

Australia claims fou...


August 14, 2015

Australia - What you...



July 30, 2015

International studen...


July 26, 2015

UK Visas and Immigra...


June 26, 2015

WHAT POTENTIAL SKILL...


June 25, 2015

Australia - Internat...


June 24, 2015

South Australia to b...


June 23, 2015

Immigrant ambassador...


June 20, 2015

Australia - Simplifi...


June 16, 2015

Integration report s...


June 15, 2015

'White, fat, and the...


June 14, 2015

Australia's successf...


June 10, 2015

New panel to tackle ...












April 30, 2015

Scholarships to Help...


April 29, 2015

Immigrants come to C...


April 27, 2015

Refugee crisis: Euro...


April 21, 2015

Five million visas i...


April 15, 2015

Chinese students fav...


April 13, 2015

Chinese one-third of...


April 12, 2015

Australia wants to b...


April 8, 2015

4 Ways International...


April 1, 2015

Queensland outshone,...


March 30, 2015

Australia's populati...


March 28, 2015

UC Berkeley first un...


March 27, 2015

European politicians...


March 25, 2015

'Wave-like' sculptur...


March 24, 2015

USA - Universities w...


March 23, 2015

Welcome event kicks ...


March 22, 2015

Law degree the new a...


March 21, 2015

Australia - Federal ...


March 18, 2015

Germany looks to Can...


March 16, 2015

Canada - Conservativ...


March 15, 2015

Asian Auckland: How ...


March 14, 2015

Australia - Pacific ...


March 12, 2015

Why the world is cra...


March 10, 2015

'Gidday mate' echoes...



March 7, 2015

Australia needs 250,...


March 5, 2015

Canada's Millionaire...


March 5, 2015

Foreign students 'vi...


March 4, 2015

Immigration main sou...


March 4, 2015

Australia - Court pr...


March 3, 2015

UK losing out to US ...


March 2, 2015

Record NZ migration ...


March 2, 2015

Record 900,000 inter...


February 28, 2015

A different immigrat...


February 28, 2015

International Ventur...


February 27, 2015

Canada - Critics cal...


February 25, 2015

Australia - Signific...


February 24, 2015

Australia boots out ...


February 16, 2015

Europe must open bor...


February 15, 2015

Canada losing lucrat...


February 13, 2015

NZ: International st...


February 12, 2015

New immigration rule...


February 11, 2015

How international st...


February 8, 2015

Why Canada’s immig...


February 8, 2015

Special migration pr...


February 8, 2015

Australia’s migran...


February 8, 2015

Quebec to launch con...


January 31, 2015

Regional Job Creatio...


January 31, 2015

Malaysian universiti...


January 29, 2015

International studen...


January 29, 2015

Overseas workers wil...


January 27, 2015

Demographic Trends: ...


January 27, 2015

Canada’s immigrati...


January 26, 2015

Australia Day Honour...


January 25, 2015

Mohammed determined ...


January 18, 2015

New Canada immigrati...


January 11, 2015

NSW - Fastest among ...


January 5, 2015

A Vast Migration Tra...


December 29, 2014

More than 62,000 peo...


December 28, 2014

Record number of asy...


December 24, 2014

Australian points-ba...


December 22, 2014

The speech that chan...


December 12, 2014

Call to change NZ im...


December 10, 2014

Study Shows Australi...


December 7, 2014

Australia migrant bi...


December 6, 2014

Who's been coming to...


December 5, 2014

Rising number of Ita...


November 26, 2014

Melbourne named the ...


November 18, 2014

Acceptable English t...


November 12, 2014

Commonwealth Exchang...


November 9, 2014

Cricket World Cup to...


November 2, 2014

Survey launched to f...


August 20, 2014

Melbourne is the wor...


August 19, 2014

Melbourne Crowned Fr...





June 22, 2014

Interstate migration...


June 22, 2014

Reaching out to new ...


June 22, 2014

Australia offers asy...


June 17, 2014

The Soccer Fan's Arg...


June 16, 2014

Australian Economic ...



June 15, 2014

Failed asylum seeker...








February 10, 2014

AU and NZ Remain Dre...


January 27, 2014

Australia's foreign-...


January 19, 2014

SA Liberals say attr...


January 12, 2014

Australian migration...


January 12, 2014

Morrison says skille...


November 29, 2013

DIBP Releases 2012-1...


November 19, 2013

Great news for Inter...


November 10, 2013

Increase in permanen...


October 12, 2013

DIAC changes name to...


August 30, 2013

Melbourne makes it t...






April 27, 2013

Australia to Continu...


April 26, 2013

Victoria calls for f...


April 10, 2013

PERTH is now home to...


March 12, 2013

Australia now has th...


March 12, 2013

If you're against im...


March 12, 2013

Australia Relaxes To...


December 3, 2012

Engineers - Get CDR ...


CONTACT US

eduaid - Asia Pacific
Australia Offices

Melbourne
Level 2 Riverside Quay
1 Southbank Boulevard, Southbank
VIC 3006
T: +61 3 9982 4458

Google Map - Melbourne, Australia

Sydney
Level 57, MLC Centre
19-29 Martin Place, Sydney
NSW 2000
T: +61 2 9238 6352

M: +61 (0) 401 224 465
      +61 (0) 412 586 958

Google Map - Sydney, Australia
eduaid - South Asia
Bangladesh Office

House 66-A (1st Floor), Road 8/A, Dhanmondi
T: +88 (02) 9110246
M: +88017 3333 2267 - 72

Google Map - Dhaka, Bangladesh
eduaid - Europe
Ireland Office
Apt 31, Wolfe Tone Lofts
Wolfe Tone Street
Dublin 1
T: +353899742487
Follow Us On